Electric versus pneumatic
Aaron Dietrich of Tolomatic, whose products are available in the UK through Motion Control Products, provides a comparison of electric actuators and pneumatic cylinders based on total cost of ownership.
Pneumatic cylinder actuators, known for their low initial cost and durability, have been a staple in factory automation equipment for decades. They are simple, easy to maintain and provide reasonable control over machine movements in industrial plants. However, since the development of more flexible, precise and reliable electric actuators, there has been an ongoing debate over which technology offers the best overall solution for industrial plant optimisation.
The case for switching to electric actuators has focused on the ability of electric actuators to achieve more precise control of motion, along with providing superior accuracy and repeatability. But there is also total cost of ownership to consider, focusing on efficiency, electric utility costs, air leaks, maintenance, product replacement, product quality, changeover time and cycle times.
For most applications requiring linear motion, the efficiency differences between an electric and a pneumatic system can result in significantly different electric utility costs over the lifetime of the device. While efficency of electric actuators is typically in the order of 80%, efficiency of pneumatic systems can vary from 10-30% depending on air quality, seal quality and wear, leaks in the system infrastructure and a variety of other factors.
All pneumatic systems or infrastructures experience leaks, and these can be problematic to identify and fix. Large leaks are more readily detected and corrected, but small leaks are challenging to identify. In fact, the accumulation of many small, unidentified air leaks can significantly increase the cost of electric bills for manufacturing companies, and it has been estimated that about 30% of air supply created for production is lost to leaks.
Pneumatic actuators rely very heavily on tight rod and piston seals to prevent air leaks. As the actuator strokes back and forth many thousands or even millions of times, seal wear and leaks are inevitable, which degrade the performance of the pneumatic cylinder and increase costs. As a result, efficiency, force output, speed and/or responsiveness of the cylinder decrease as air leakage increases. All of these factors inhibit the consistent manufacturing processes required for high quality, high volume production.
Furthermore, predicting when the seals may fail or anticipating their effect on performance can be almost impossible to determine. Maintenance personnel and operators in plants can spend endless hours adjusting the flow or regulation of air into individual devices to get proper operation. Once this process begins, many plants and manufacturing facilities start to put pneumatic cylinders on a preventative maintenance replacement or repair schedule to get more consistent operation. This process introduces costs for time, labour and effort.
By comparison, electric actuators demand very little or no maintenance. With some actuators an occasional re-lubrication may be required, but for the most part, electric actuators require no ongoing maintenance. Furthermore, electric actuators primarily utilise ball screw and ball bearing technology which can provide a more predictable estimation of service life compared to pneumatics.
Further, the performance of a pneumatic cylinder varies over time as the seals wear. As a result, many adjustments of the pneumatic system may be required to get repeatable or accurate performance over the life of the device. Any change in the performance of a pneumatic cylinder can directly relate to the quality and yield of the product being produced in the manufacturing process.
System vibration can also be a performance concern. Typically, pneumatic cylinders are deployed in 'bang-bang' end-to-end applications where they move to two positions to perform the desired operation. Even though cushions or shock absorbers can be added to pneumatic cylinders to help soften the vibration at the end of each move, in many cases the motion of the pneumatic cylinder is less controlled than its electric actuator counterpart. An electric actuator can therefore prevent introduction of shock or vibration disturbances into the system caused by the motion.
The superior control (accuracy and repeatability) of an electric actuator system also leads to better overall control of the manufacturing process and higher product quality and yield.
Applications that require product changeovers and multiple setups will often benefit from conversion to electric actuators. For example, if a process or machine requires changeover or setup to run different sizes or different products in the same machine, then an electric actuator can automate that changeover. If the application involves adjusting hard-stops for pneumatic cylinder positioning, this too can be automated with programming in an electric system. While a pneumatic system often requires adding rod-lock spacers to the cylinder to gain different or multiple positions, in an electric system this can simply be programmed.
With any of these examples, there is a good chance an electric actuator will solve problems with the changeover processes. The adjustment of hard-stops or addition of spacers on rods for positioning can be time consuming, prone to human error and can reduce process quality if adjustments are not accurate or the wrong rod spacers are used in some or all axes of motion. Electric actuators can be used either in lower duty cycle setup axes or in high-cyclic, process-important axes due to their complete control over position and motion profile (velocity, acceleration/ deceleration, force).
Of course, every process is different, but it logically follows that if changeovers become much quicker then there is less time spent adjusting machines and more time spent producing product. Additionally, there are potential savings from reduced manual labour and the elimination of human errors in the production process.
Another important factor to consider is cycle time. Compare the profitability of investing in improvements to cycle time and the overall throughput and efficiency of the equipment. That will help in weighing the benefits of replacing pneumatic actuators with electric actuators.
Pneumatic cylinders are typically deployed as two-position devices. If a process has any tooling which must be moved out of the way for a changeover process or other process reason, then the pneumatic cylinder must be purchased with the full stroke in mind. During runtime, this means that the pneumatic cylinder must cycle back and forth across its full stroke even if it is not required for the runtime process, which increases production time. Furthermore, if the pneumatic cylinder is required to develop force in this process, additional delays can be introduced because the cylinder must build up air pressure to achieve the desired force.
Typically this doesn't take a lot of time (usually 10s or 100s of milliseconds) but it is nonetheless wasted time in every cycle and it is cumulative. Again, an electric actuator can eliminate both of these problems. The electric actuator can stroke the tooling only as much as is needed, saving valuable cycle time. Additionally, electric actuators can develop force almost instantaneously because their force is directly equivalent to the electrical current through the motor. This eliminates any wait time in the process for developing pressure in the pneumatic cylinder to achieve force.
It is not uncommon for plant management to anguish over the higher initial purchased cost of electric technology even though they are aware of the benefits: higher quality product, higher product yields, higher throughput, lower operating costs, lower maintenance costs, and shorter changeover times.
Ignoring TCO will definitely result in short-term equipment cost savings, but it will come with increased utility costs, increased maintenance costs and increased product yield issues over the long run. Considering TCO early in the process of specifying equipment is all about considering the entire service life of a technology choice, not just the initial purchase cost. If the TCO concept is truly embraced by manufacturing companies, the analysis would show that in most cases choosing electric actuators over equipment requiring compressed air (pneumatic devices) will almost always provide a lower TCO.
Other News from Motion Control Products

Latest news about Linear acctuators
- Transport balls screws from Abssac
- Linear actuators the preferred solution for agricultural OEMs
- Actuators provide a low maintenance solution in a high duty bread manufacturing application
- Compact ServoWeld actuators from Tolomatic deliver high force in a small package
- New rod-style stainless steel actuator for food and beverage applications
- Thomson adds CANopen networking protocol option for Electrak HD actuators
- Thomson introduces compact electromechanical linear actuators with embedded CAN Bus support and PLC capability
- Investing in skills and technologies proves key
- ElectroCraft expands the AxialPower family of linear actuators with the APES 17
- compact electromechanical linear actuators with embedded CANbus support and PLC capability
- High force integrated actuator reduces footprint and extends service life
- Robots get greater range with plug-and-play linear actuators
- The force awakens
- Universal torque wrench calibration
- Going beyond just servo valves for auto test labs
- Proportional solenoids just got even smaller
- High force actuators: convert from hydraulic to electric
- Considerations for selecting electric actuators for harsh environments
- Screw jacks design guide for automation
- A quick guide to selecting the best linear motion product
- The motion control solution with higher load density
- Igus expands leadscrew range with iglidur E7 nuts
- Micro gripper allows fragile part handling to 2.5g force
- Actuators keep Sperry Rail on track
- Articulate gantries keep axle production moving
- Linear actuator drive choice is a precise balancing act
- Actuator is adaptable to a range of applications
- Reliance launches new actuators catalogue
- Lifting Cathedral’s dais to new heights
- Redesigned linear stages improve your process by up to 98%
- LG Motion delivers a perfect soft landing with moving coil actuators from SMAC
- New ideas in linear motion
- How to specify simple, reliable and adaptable screw jacks
- Modular design for electric actuators
- Zimmer clamping and breaking MBPS from Moore International
- New high load precision linear module from SKF
- New recirculating units offer unlimited stroke
- XY piezo nanopositioning stages with 50x50mm aperture
- Igus drylin ZLW for linear robotic applications
- Electric cylinders offer high power and speed
- Actuator switch delivers 89% energy savings
- Electromechanical joining module
- IP rated products from SMAC-MCA
- Haptic accelerator pedals improved
- Discovering the benefits of electromechanical actuation
- How to specify simple, reliable screw jacks
- Electric versus pneumatics
- Planetary screw drive offers high load carrying capacity and high power density
- Guideways, stages and ballscrews, plus accessories
- Miniature actuation solutions for Steeper's bebionic hand
- Trends in specifications for industrial linear actuators
- Inkoma KSH bevel gear high speed screw jacks from Francis and Francis
- Microsite showcases benefits of electric linear actuators in off-highway applications
- Electric throttle control for mechanical diesel engines
- Fast actuator delivery for machine builders
- Servo motor driven ballscrew key to car seat test system
- Linear drive technology aids PCB production throughput
- Back to basics on linear motion systems
- Warner Linear supplies actuators for all-terrain vehicles
- HepcoMotion linear actuators boost safety at packaging plant
- Integrated XY ball-screw stage for cost-sensitive planar performance
- Linear actuators
- Intelligent stepper motor linear stages
- Moore International at Southern Manufacturing 2014
- Eight tonne load driven into oven
- Self-lubricating and compact, drylin E offers a complete drive solution, with axis and motor
- New Generation of drylin Linear Axes for food and beverage applications
- Electric cylinders deliver control and flexibility
- High acceleration, high load and smooth running
- Linear solutions for heavier loads
- Low friction positioning and transportation
- Powerful, precise option for linear positioning tasks
- Robust and reliable electric linear actuation
- Screw drives for machine building and automation
- Simulator improves race cars and driver training
- Smooth, accurate, linear positioning systems
- Schaeffler extends ballscrew drives to include new rolled version
- Linear actuation for hovercraft steering
- Moore International to distribute Schneeberger
- Selecting lead screws
- Fully integrated linear actuator and rolling bearing units designed for solar tracking systems
- Sun seekers
- The future belongs to electric actuation
- High-speed axis features roller bearings for higher performance
- Optimised motion series provides cost-effective motion control
- Cost-effective linear motion for a wide range of applications
- Bomb disposal robot gets extra lift with actuator
- Raising the stakes
- igus linear drive modules for extreme conditions
- Miniature linear actuator offers stroke lengths of up to 250mm
- Linear actuators ensure precise positioning of sheet metal parts for transformer cores
- Actuators compatible with profile system
- Linear actuator speeds up pick and place processes
- Screw jacks for hygiene conscious tasks
- Servo press module equipped with wireless telemetry for clean rooms
- Simple solution found for heavy duty linear actuator
- Heavy-duty linear axis with belt drive or ball screw
- Linear actuators enable faster delivery of prescription medication to patients
- Adapter kit enables linear bearing systems to be built easily
- Small, lightweight and lubricant-free system for positioning small loads
- New electro hydrostatic design concept unveiled
- Welding guns rely on ballscrews
- Renewable Energy in Motion
- Back to basics on ball screws
- Electric cylinders
- Folded over motorised linear rail system
- Servo actuators provide a boost for machine productivity
- NSK achieves 40% cost reduction for welding gun manufacturer
- Linear motion technology
- Maximum precision from spindle drives
- Penny and Giles integrates Mechetronics into its controls division
- Lubricant-free linear drive fully assembled with NEMA motor
- Electric alternative to screw or belt drives
- Novel bi-parting drive cuts the cost of machine automation
- Linear motion: myth and reality
- Rack and pinion drive system
- Roof lift improves composting
- Linear actuators bring greater flexibility to automation
- Cost effective alternative to pneumatic actuators
- Screw jacks
- Compact, precise external actuator
- Greater choice needed as Britain automates
- Lightweight face tests respirator seals
- Linear actuation for Advanced Gun System for the US Navy
- Medical leadscrews in miniature sizes
- Short stroke electric cylinder uses tubular linear motor
- Compact actuator delivers reliability for film winding
- High performance in a small package
- Heason Technology is appointed Premier Partner for Danaher Motion's Thomson brand
- Power Jacks provides the lift for aero engine transport
- All-in-one motion package
- Performance cylinders based on innovative tubular linear motor
- Stainless steel linear motor
- The advantage of large journal at rolled screw cost
- Festo enters low-cost electric actuator market
- All-in-one actuator package is an easy to specify option
- From light duties to the most rugged
- Guide ball bushing for miniature sizes
- High speed linear motion
- Linear actuators with embedded force sensors
- Linear motion package suits clean room tasks
- Screw jacks weigh up the universe
- Vacuum-through shaft actuator eliminates common dust problems
- Belt driven actuator is a really fast mover
- Linear motion products
- Power Jacks Helps Wimbledon Play On
- Safe work access for nuclear containers
- Actuators drive ground printing machines
- Ballscrews take to the sky
- Driven to provide greater capacity
- Increased safety and longer life
- Actuators ideal where space is tight
- All-in-one linear actuator technology is on a roll
- Linear actuator offers higher force
- Rack actuator offers precision and efficiency
- Actuators reduce package size and cost
- Direct drive modules increase throughput
- Linear drives range boosts performance
- Actuators go stainless
- Corrosion-free screw jacks
- Electrics oust pneumatics
- Left handed and right handed lead screws
- Linear actuators now have inbuilt force measuring option
- Mechatronic assemblies integrate intelligence
- Push or pull the heaviest of loads
- Radical new option for linear motion
- Modularising machine design and build
- Actuation systems
- A more productive plant
- Drive systems
- Electromechanical actuators prove a good fit for joining
- Off the shelf connectors for parallel motion
- Mechatronic assistance tidal simulation project
- Opening doors for neutrons
- Precision three-in-one servo actuators
- Should you build or buy?
- Telescopic pillars suit medical tables
- Virtually unlimited lift in a space saving package
- The myths of converting to electric actuators debunked
- Belt actuator combines accuracy and durability
- Automation made simple with linear motion technology