Camozzi Automation UK highlights the key considerations for machine builders and engineers when selecting motion control technologies, from positioning accuracy and energy efficiency to long-term operating costs.
As manufacturers continue to invest in automation, machine builders and engineers face an important decision when designing or upgrading equipment: should they specify pneumatic or electric actuation?
Both technologies have established roles in industrial automation, but with increasing pressure to improve productivity, reduce energy consumption and develop more flexible machinery, understanding their respective capabilities is becoming increasingly important.
Camozzi Automation UK, a specialist in pneumatic and electric motion control technologies, is encouraging OEMs and engineering teams to take an application-led approach to actuator selection, rather than assuming one technology is inherently better than the other.
Understanding the differences
Pneumatic actuation remains a practical and widely used solution for many industrial applications, particularly those requiring straightforward, repeatable movements between defined positions.
Using compressed air to generate movement, pneumatic cylinders are commonly found in automated assembly equipment, packaging machinery and material handling systems, where they perform tasks such as clamping, gripping, lifting and transferring components.
Electric actuation, meanwhile, offers greater flexibility where programmable positioning and controlled motion profiles are required. Electromechanical cylinders combine an electric motor and mechanical transmission to deliver controlled linear movement, making them particularly suitable for applications requiring multiple stopping positions, precise adjustment or frequent product changeovers.
However, selecting between these technologies involves more than comparing positioning capabilities.
Four key factors in actuator selection
According to Camozzi, engineers should consider four principal areas when assessing the most suitable actuation technology.
1. Positioning and motion control: The first consideration is what the movement needs to achieve. For applications requiring movement between two defined positions, conventional pneumatic cylinders may provide an effective solution. Where intermediate positioning, variable speeds or programmable motion profiles are necessary, electric actuation may offer greater flexibility.
2. Force, speed and stroke: Actuator selection must account for the working load, required stroke, cycle time and acceleration, alongside mounting arrangements and potential side loads. Pneumatic force depends on the available pressure and effective piston area, while electric actuator performance is determined by the motor and transmission system.
Understanding these operating conditions is essential to ensuring reliable performance throughout the movement.
3. Operating environment and machine safety: Environmental conditions can significantly influence actuator selection. Exposure to dust, moisture, washdown procedures and temperature extremes must be considered, alongside available installation space and the appropriate level of component protection. Machine safety is equally important. Engineers must assess how the system will respond to a loss of compressed air or electrical power, including any requirements for controlled stopping or load holding.
4. Energy efficiency and total cost of ownership: With energy costs remaining an important consideration for UK manufacturers, efficiency is increasingly influencing automation investment decisions. However, replacing pneumatic equipment with electric alternatives does not automatically guarantee energy savings.
Pneumatic energy consumption is influenced by operating pressure, air usage, compressor efficiency and system leakage. Electric systems have their own energy requirements, including motor efficiency and standby or holding demands.
A meaningful comparison should therefore consider the complete operating cycle, installation requirements, maintenance and long-term costs, rather than focusing solely on the initial purchase price.
Combining technologies for greater flexibility
Importantly, machine builders do not always need to choose one technology over the other.
Hybrid automation systems can combine pneumatic and electric technologies to take advantage of their individual strengths.
For example, an electric axis may provide programmable positioning within a pick-and-place application, while pneumatic grippers perform component handling at each location.
Servopneumatic technology also provides an alternative for applications requiring more sophisticated pneumatic control.
Camozzi's Series 6PF position feedback cylinders, when integrated with suitable proportional valves and control systems, can be used in servopneumatic applications requiring position feedback or controlled force.
For applications requiring electromechanical movement, Camozzi's Series 3E and 6E cylinders provide options for programmable positioning and controlled linear motion.
These technologies give engineers greater flexibility when developing automation systems around specific performance requirements.
Supporting UK machine builders
With expertise across pneumatic, electric and hybrid technologies, Camozzi Automation UK supports OEMs, machine builders and engineering teams in identifying suitable motion control solutions. Its UK-based technical team provides application support, while its dedicated Automation Centre offers capabilities including bespoke pneumatic and electro-pneumatic control assemblies.
By considering the complete application, including positioning, force, operating environment, efficiency and long-term costs, engineers can make more informed decisions about their automation investments.
The message from Camozzi is clear: successful actuator selection is not about choosing pneumatic over electric, but identifying the most appropriate technology, or combination of technologies, for the job.
The Fluid Power Centre
Watling Street
CV11 6BQ
UNITED KINGDOM
+44 (0)24 7637 4114