A worked example for ROI on a dispensing robot

Peter Swanson, managing director of adhesives and dispensing equipment specialist Intertronics, shares a hypothetical worked example of the ROI of a dispensing robot for an electronics CEM.

The benefits of robotics are well known: improved productivity, efficiency, output, quality, and flexibility. In addition to their production benefits, they can improve health and safety and job satisfaction for employees. However, these things can be difficult to quantify against upfront costs, leaving some businesses unclear about whether their investment will deliver business value.

Here is an imagined scenario: I am the managing director of an electronics CEM. We make 1,000 potted electronics assemblies per week, regularly 200 per day. This is done manually by experienced operators. Pat is my best operator, she’s been with me the longest time.

Some weeks, about 2.5% of these are rejected after potting. Each one costs £50, so I lose £1,250 that week. The potting compound has to be mixed by hand, and dispensed into the assembly without voids or bubbles. It’s a bit of a messy and tricky job, in an area of the factory I’m not proud of.

Sometimes I have capacity problems, when the operators, especially Pat, are on holiday or sick. I worry about Pat, as she has talked to me about reducing her hours or retiring. It would be better if I could de-skill this operation to take some risk out of it.

If I invested £30,000 to £40,000 in a robot to mix the potting material and apply it automatically, we could get through all 1,000 units in half a day each week. We would still need an operator to load/unload the robot, but that could be done with someone less experienced. We think that the reject rate would go down to about 1% (and with work we could get it lower as we reduce the process variables). There would be less handling of the chemicals, improving the health and safety of my team.

Installing this automation would allow us to reallocate 4.5 days per week on labour to something more useful, saving us about £35,000 per year in labour overhead on this assembly. With the savings on rejects of about £20,000 per year, a really simple ROI sum says that we would pay off the investment in less than 12 months.

Our customer for this product has been making noises about raising the quantities from 1,000 to 10,000 per week. If that happens, we would need to hire nine more people and train them, but in this labour market, that will be really difficult. I need to keep the people I have by giving them less monotonous, more engaging work. So if we get the increased order, we would have to make the robot investment. However, I am worried that we won’t get the job unless we get our reject rate down.

One of my competitors has some of its robots pictured on its website, which makes it look really professional and up to date. Raising our image and brand would be another benefit of investing in automation, although it’s a bit more difficult to put a number on the financial value.

In conversation with our dispensing supplier, I realised that this level of automation costs much less than I thought – less than my new car. I think we can justify the cost through a fast ROI, deskilling some jobs, motivating our workforce, upping our image, and reducing risk both commercially and in production.”

Intertronics

Station Field Industrial Estate
Banbury Road
Kidlington
OX5 1JD
UNITED KINGDOM

+44 (0)1865 842842

info@intertronics.co.uk

www.intertronics.co.uk

More products
NSK bearings help pet food plant raise OEE
When a major UK pet food producer wanted better machine utilisation with the aim of raising its OEE (overall equipment effectiveness) by 3 points, it asked experts at bearing specialist NSK if they could evaluate processes and systems to help with this improvement goal.
NORD DRIVESYSTEMS has “inspiring discussions” at SPS
Drive specialist NORD DRIVESYSTEMS reports a highly success time at the SPS trade fair in Nuremberg, with three intensive days on the topic of efficient drive solutions for the automation industry.
A Christmas gift with every GS Yuasa battery
GS Yuasa has unwrapped its latest promotion – a Christmas present with every battery. Whether you’re buying a battery for a Pyronix alarm system or a Peugeot – qualifying purchases of both GS and Yuasa batteries throughout December will include a festive freebie.
Beckhoff UK and HepcoMotion’s mechatronics showcase takes centre stage
Automation technology specialist Beckhoff UK, in collaboration with leading manufacturer of linear motion systems, HepcoMotion, hosted a mechatronics showcase at MK7, the home of Oracle Red Bull Racing in Milton Keynes, with several innovations from both companies on display, as well as a brand-new product reveal – the GFX-r guidance system.
PPMA re-brand puts automation at the heart of UK manufacturing
The PPMA Group of Associations has re-branded and has changed its name to AutomateUK to better represent the needs of its membership and their end user customers in the ever-changing manufacturing landscape.
steute Technologies restructures its business fields
steute Technologies, an international technology company offering switches, intelligent sensors and wireless systems, has announced a comprehensive restructuring of its business fields.
Young designers take off with e-racing cars and support from norelem
Set around the challenge to build and operate a purely electric racing car, this year’s Formula Student (Electric) competition put student designers to the test. To prepare several teams for the event, the VDI Racing Camp powered by norelem brought together more than 250 participants from across Germany, preparing them for the prestigious competition by providing components and support to each team.
Showcasing design, production and process engineering in the food and drink sect
Taking place on 1 May 2024 at the National Motorcycle Museum, Food Manufacturing Live serves the design, production, process and maintenance engineering teams across the UK food and drink manufacturing sector.
Understanding safety and security for the protection of human and machine
How do you master employee protection, liability protection, productivity and data protection? How do you increase your quality and simultaneously prevent manipulation on your machines? How do you protect your data and employees in equal measure? Pilz is hosting a free webinar on 15 December, 9:30-10:30 am, to address just these questions.
Schaffner opens new regional channels for its range of EMC solutions
EMC solutions provider, Schaffner, announces new partnerships with three distributors to further broaden the reach and scope of its product range and support services across Europe. The new agreements with Telerex, CATS and DSL Components will open new supplier corridors and enable customers to have local and faster access to products.

Login / Sign up