Closing the loop to keep your stepper in position
Stepper motors are a common solution for controlling the position of moving components, but in some cases can be inadequate since the motor position is not necessarily known. Gerard Bush of Inmoco and Peter Vandermeulen of PMD consider the use of stepper motors in closed loop architectures.
Stepper motors have proven themselves as capable performers in a vast range of applications, offering an inexpensive solution when compared to brushless motors. For good reason, the stepper motor is frequently the first choice in cost-sensitive applications that can tolerate less accurate positioning.
In the vast majority of cases, stepper motors are operated in open loop architectures, with engineers tending to look at alternative motor solutions in critical applications where care has to be taken to ensure that, when a command is given to the motor controller, the motor actually ends up where the engineer wants it to go. But could the design engineer be missing a trick? A stepper motor operating in closed loop mode can offer some advantages over the use of a brushless motor even in critical applications. The servo stepper motor will almost always be lower in cost and offer a higher torque density than a brushless motor.
At the same time, even in more standard applications where one would typically use a stepper motor in an open loop mode, there can be advantages to closing the loop with an encoder, where the net cost savings from using a smaller motor could outweigh the cost of the encoder, and deliver performance advantages to boot. So let us consider the various options for stepper motor architectures, which include the open loop stepper motor, the sensorless stepper motor, the stepper motor with encoder and the fully closed loop stepper motor.
The typical open loop stepper motor architecture drives the motor with a constant winding current without regard to loading or true motor position. With no true position feedback, the motor is generally over-sized to ensure that it will always overcome torque requirements, but still there is no guarantee that the motor’s end position will be close to the target position – which means a large potential position error has to be factored into the design.
Encoderless stall detection technologies exist that purport to overcome this lack of information. This architecture does not employ an encoder but instead attempts to derive the rotor location by others means. Various techniques exist such as detecting back EMF voltage on a passive phase or measuring current rise times. However, there is still no guarantee that the motor is actually at the proper position. In the context of mission critical applications this may not provide adequate knowledge about the motor’s position. Further, encoderless stall detection techniques are notoriously difficult to implement since dependencies exist on both the minimum speed required for this technique to work and on the load on the motor (which can be dynamic).
In a typical stepper motor, the position error is proportional to the loading, which will be dominated by friction at steady state speeds and dominated by inertia during acceleration and deceleration. However, over time and with dynamic load conditions, this situation can change due to aging of belts, bearings and other secondary effects.
Closing the loop
Adding a position loop to the stepper motor architecture requires that position feedback – through some form of a position encoder at some minimal resolution – be added. In the simplest configuration, operating the stepper motor with an encoder, the feedback ensures that the controller can verify that the motor is in the desired position. If not, the controller can adjust by providing additional steps, either in real-time during the move when position errors are detected, or post move. This allows the motor size to be reduced as the encoder gives a positive indication of the position problem.
But we can go a stage further with this encoder, by using the stepper motor in a fully closed loop configuration, which adjusts the torque requirements in real time, and is able to calculate the appropriate motor current and current phase angle. The ability to calculate the appropriate motor current (torque) enables the system to compensate for position error resulting from frictional or inertial loads. Since the rotor angle is known, the controller can calculate a motor current phase angle which optimises the torque response and makes the delivered torque predictable.
This new closed loop stepper motor architecture – also referred to as the servo stepper – can decrease motor size and cost, improve motor efficiency and accuracy, and reduce noise, heat and maintenance. Why can motor size be reduced in close loop architectures? Open loop architectures cannot detect a lost step since it cannot be detected, so the motor will be oversized (often by a factor of 2 or more) in order to increase torque margin to ensure there are no lost steps. The existence of an encoder which can detect a lost step will reduce the torque margin and this allows for a much smaller motor.
There are efficiency benefits too, since the controller’s optimisation of the motor current phase means the greatest possible torque is being generated by the motor for a given current. Much less electrical power will be used to generate the same amount of mechanical power.
In terms of accuracy, the position error in a closed loop architecture will be smaller since the position loop will continuously command a torque in an attempt to compensate for any position error. This will have a positive effect on both positional and velocity accuracy
Another disadvantage of open loop stepper systems is that the excess electrical power is dissipated as excess motor heat. The motor will run much cooler in a closed loop system since most of the electrical energy will be translated into kinetic energy instead of thermal energy. Closed loop operation reduces vibration and will result in quieter operation. Further, because the closed loop stepper motor runs at lower temperatures, it will have a longer service life, reducing maintenance implications.
This is not to say that the closed loop architecture will be the best or the right solution in every application. The open loop architecture has its own set of advantages including set-up time, system start up, cost and space requirements. And if the loading on the motor is highly deterministic then the possibility of a ‘lost step’ is reduced anyway. In that case, the position error can be estimated as a function of the loading, making the position accuracy known and the use of an open loop architecture feasible.
However, in more critical applications such as medical devices, this may still not be an adequate guarantee of position. Hence the need to add an encoder to ensure that the position is known at all times.
Even if the accuracy of an open loop system is deemed to be acceptable, there might still be advantages in turning to a closed loop architecture if motor efficiency is a factor. For example, if the system uses a battery as a power supply, the improved efficiency from a closed loop solution will be beneficial even though the position accuracy of the open loop solution may be adequate. Another example would be if the motor is in an environment where the increased thermal energy or noise levels emitted from the open loop system are not tolerable or desirable.
We can see, then, that in a host of different applications with different operational requirements, there can be good reasons to explore the potential of operating a stepper motor in a closed loop architecture – even in applications where the standard open loop performance might be deemed acceptable.
Other News from Intelligent Motion Control (Inmoco)

Latest news about Electric motors
- EMS supplies the latest innovation in stepper motors with internal aperture
- Partnership looks to transform rehabilitation technology
- Engineering mobility with rehabilitation exoskeletons
- ABB Food Safe motors withstand over 1,100 washdown cycles
- Carpanelli motors direct from the manufacturer with cost savings
- Motion in medical analysers
- Maxon develops ultra-efficient UAV drive with startup Flybotix
- Motors help aircraft make the most out of their fuel
- New brushless DC motor from Portescap with integrated drive saves space and time
- Selecting the optimum motor technology for an application
- At-sea rewind restores performance and reliability for offshore vessel
- Electrocraft introduces MPW series wheel drive for mobile robot applications
- EMS has supported the next generation of lighting system and camera platform innovation
- Torque motors feature variable assembly options for optimisation
- Weg supplies electric motor for Repsol hyper compressor
- Schaeffler provides custom rotating direct drive motor for one of the world’s largest reflecting telescopes
- Autoclavable DC motors ease surgical power tool design
- When a servo motor that’s big enough isn’t big enough
- Revisited: The effect of repairs on motor efficiency
- Small but mighty
- Weg designs bespoke motors for mine ventilation system
- Maxon hosts medical device webinar in August
- ABB’s AXW water-cooled Large AC motors offer power density with less maintenance
- Higher and faster: motors for elevators
- High precision and reliable voice coil motor outperforms in medical ventilator applications
- Miniature motors for tattoo machines
- High performance motors from Lafert
- Stainless gear motors provide double hygienic solution
- ABB IE5 SynRM motors deliver ultra-premium energy efficiency – 50% better than IE2 motors
- Carpanelli introduces antibacterial and stainless motors and gearboxes
- Servo motors and drives from Lafert
- Frameless motors for high performance motion control
- Carpanelli extends motor range to include NEMA dimensions
- Ultra-compact servo motors from Motec have integrated drives
- Using micromotors to provide relief for dental patients
- Using micromotors to provide dental patient relief
- Dynamic motor test is improving equipment reliability for EDF energy
- Innovative hollow shaft rotary actuators
- Size 6 brushless slotted DC motors for arthroscopic applications
- New Power over EtherNet enabled miniature integrated servomotor
- Asynchronous motors provide a first in energy saving
- Integrated servo motors
- Schaeffler presents electric motors ready for volume production
- Why motor size matters
- GPS for the Milky Way
- Reliance introduce EtherCAT to Cool Muscle motor range
- Unmanned ground vehicles ideal for dull, dirty and dangerous tasks
- ABB appoints Betech as UK provider for NEMA motors
- ABB launches IEC food safe motors
- Enormous acceleration with disc magnet technology
- Torque motors offered with watertight cooling jacket
- DC motors with built-in intelligence
- Flat DC-servomotors with more torque
- Frameless brushless motors offer advantages for machine automation
- The first Mars helicopter will fly with Swiss DC motors
- Show(ering) keeps going on
- Hollow shaft direct drive torque motors
- New control electronics for integrated motors
- Why frameless motors?
- Custom motor design
- New microstepping drive range
- ISS artificial crew member relies on Faulhaber drive
- Supporting older servo equipment
- Custom motor design
- Keep your old servos
- Increased efficiency and greater power
- Miniature motors bring new capabilities to prosthetic limbs
- Robotic exoskeletons boost quality of life
- Capactive encoders for microstepping motors
- Motor change saves a fish feed producer 135,000kWh per year
- Servo motors with maximum torque density
- ACM2n servo motors
- Smaller than an AC motor, and more cost-effective than a servo
- Powerful, cost-effective motor
- Schaeffler takes over remainder of Compact Dynamics
- Extremely compact distributed drive solution
- Why do DC motors have brushes?
- Integrated drive motors on show at SPS IPC Drives 2017
- Second generation linear motor from Piezomotor
- Custom motor design
- DC motors for electronic gear shift
- Harsh environment stepper motors
- Insulation damage at the heart of motor problems
- Brushless DC servomotor extends BP4 product family
- Once again, NASA relies on Maxon technology
- Miniature motors prove key for reliable sewer robots
- Powerful, compact DC motors from Maxon
- The flyweight that packs a heavyweight punch
- Powerful DC micro-motors key to innovative motorised golf trolley
- A new concept in electric motors
- Considerations for OEMs selecting electric motors
- Outer rotor motor with integrated drive
- Record deck uses counter rotating disks to compensate for vibration
- ABB and Sulzer sign UK service agreement for large motors and generators
- Industry 4.0 grasper increases efficiency
- Compact servo motors allow precise positioning
- Miniature motors help bring greater safety to climbing
- New outer rotor brushless DC motors
- stepSERVO now available with EtherCAT interface
- Interroll and the Sauber Formula 1 continue their partnership
- More power for pumps
- Next generation of drum motors from Interroll
- Second generation linear motor from EMS
- Racing car engines use Maxon motors
- Ultra compact DC motor with gear and controller
- Getting more for less, with rare earth magnets
- Mini motor durability and performance
- Unmanned ground vehicles rely on Maxon motors
- Motors key in design of modern medical ventilator
- Pancake motor from PMW helps digitise film heritage
- Current affairs: dynamic motor testing
- Swiss motors drive exoskeletons
- Stainless steel motors for hygienic applications
- Brushless motors reach up to 40,000rpm
- Zippermast – tape measure meets zip
- World’s first modular robot system
- Intelligent motors provide all-in-one design
- In-wheel motors from PMW power innovative Rasa hydrogen car
- 300mNm torque from a 10mm brushed motor
- Static motor testing improves reliability
- Asynchronous brushless motors
- Compact all-in-one drive from Dunkermotoren
- DC drive makes Dermamill the tool of choice for compounding pharmacists
- Reliably automating blood and stem cell banking
- Stober hollow shaft drives offer higher shaft load
- Technology for uncharted worlds
- Drive Lines and Exico UK combine their expertise to create bespoke power transmission solutions
- Miniature motors for anthropomorphic robot hand
- PMW highlights in-wheel motors at the Drives and Controls show
- Portescap wins 2016 Golden Mousetrap Award
- Special and customised motors on the Carpanelli Stand D730 at Drives and Controls 2016
- Pancake motors simplify lift door actuation
- Wide range of electric motors
- Asynchronous brushless motors
- Deep brain surgery inspired by wasps
- Dynamic test of vehicle systems
- Island of efficiency helps designers to boost performance
- Motors drive safe ‘jackup’ operations in the North Sea
- Ultra compact servo motor delivers increased flexibility
- New motor technology brings lower energy, maintenance and noise to extruder
- SME partnership promotes motor customisation
- Beyond the inverter: Tips for making motors run efficiently
- DC motors reduce the weight of electric pruning shears
- High power density brushed DC motors
- Motor-mounted inverter boards
- Optimised efficiency at water treatment facility
- Resurgence of the two-speed motor
- ElectroCraft launches Hansen motors in Europe
- How efficient are your motors really?
- Exico builds in quality management as it grows
- Motors certified for hazardous areas
- Motors for the food and drink industry at PPMA
- Motors make music
- Maxon motors key to new turntable design
- Brushless DC motor is compact and efficient
- Compact and dynamic
- Flyweight packs a heavyweight punch
- Motor controllers - build or buy?
- New pallet wrapper offers world beating performance
- Smaller motor sizes and 400 step motors expand range
- Miniature motors key for snake-arm robots
- Drive Systems are taking off in cabin equipment
- High performance drive in a small package
- Motors can combine enhanced hygiene with major cost savings
- Exico to host first open day and training seminars
- Integrated motor with Ethernet connectivity
- Minimal size and maximum power
- Maintenance-free linear motors delivery high power density
- Applied Motion Products' Integrated Step-Servo is available from Mclennan
- Elimination of motor failures saves £1000s for Weetabix
- Flyweight motor packs a heavyweight punch
- Servo systems
- Atlantic Industrie relies on Interroll's 24V drive technology
- High efficiency and stainless motors
- How do you catch a comet?
- Lafert sponsors local Italian rugby team
- Pumps support the heart by keeping blood flowing
- Stepper motors with minimal size
- Servomotor users should not be seduced by power density
- Breakthrough motor cures reliability challenges for Synseal
- Drilling to new limits
- Shielded ABB motor helps wind tunnel avoid overheating
- Dunkermotoren highlights rotary and linear electric motors at PPMA
- Installing and operating your electric motors
- Robot assisted operations with tactile dexterity
- Servo technology moving towards a new paradigm
- Small gives big benefits
- Turning food waste into nano-fibres
- New motors from Dunkermotoren at PPMA Show
- Low voltage electric motors
- ABB's new SynRM2 motor will deliver IE5 efficiency without rare earth magnets
- Smart motor reduces machine build costs
- Stepper motors are small but powerful
- Synchronous electric motors
- LG Motion and Airex Corporation set up integration partner agreement
- New configurable DC motors, gearheads and encoders from Maxon Motor
- Is your electric motor telling you something?
- Motors key in evolution of humanoid robotics
- WEG and KSB supply motors and pumps to Water-link project in Belgium
- Electric dragster built by engineers from Amtecs
- Intelligent prosthetics
- Lafert sponsors battery powered racing car team
- Power and precision for challenging tasks
- Eaton shows technology for doing things better
- WEG to exhibit world's most energy efficient range of low voltage motors
- Driving the ultimate in freedom of movement
- Emission-free emotions in the eMotorcycle World Championships
- IE4 motors deliver energy savings of up to 40%
- WEG becomes sponsor for Europump Conference in 2014
- Orbital welding bug launched
- Motor energy efficiency regulations tightened further
- ABB launches UK's largest technical channel network for drives and motors
- Increasing motor efficiency without the drawbacks
- Motor with EtherCAT comms
- Opportunity celebrates 10 years on Mars
- WEG moves to larger premises to provide faster delivery
- Smallest integrated drive/control/encoder and microstepping motor in NEMA 11
- Encoder options save space and lower the price barrier for motion control feedback
- Brake motors bring order to the ride of the Vikings
- Technology that gets under your skin
- NEMA motors from ABB available for immediate European delivery
- Configurable DC motors and gearheads
- Lenze claims quantum leap in AC motor technology
- High efficiency motors reduce installation costs
- Integrated microstepping motor and drive option
- Stainless motors maximise hygiene and minimise downtime
- Oxford to Minsk on a pint of petrol
- New square and round frame IE2 AC induction motor range
- Modular EUSAS motor meets highest quality demands
- Even higher performance in a smaller size
- Get ready for IE3
- Take the Advantage
- Motors are 25% smaller with power maintained
- Industrial grade servo motors available from Mclennan
- Increasing productivity and efficiency in the steel industry
- Smaller Piezo LEGS motor with integrated encoder
- World's first Ex-approved permanent magnet synchronous motor
- Servomotors bridge gap between stepper and induction motors
- Integrated microstepping motor now available with IP65 environmental ratings
- Direct drive linear actuators
- Integrated motor delivers accurate tidal simulation
- The future vision of sustainable mobility
- World Rescue Robot Competition - First for UK team
- Tubular linear motor takes motion control to a new level
- Maxon's 'configure and order' revolution
- Advanced techniques for stepper motors
- Brushless DC servomotor is the most compact available
- Free training: introduction to DC motor selection
- Mid performance, high torque per pound servomotor has wide usage range
- Permanent magnet motors can eliminate belts and chains
- Introducing the new 4mm micromotor and gearhead
- Festo introduces SmartInversion - a new drive concept to inspire engineers
- Launching the UK's first CubeSat mission
- WEG wins European Electric Motors for Water and Waste Water Customer Value Enhancement Award
- Low cost, high performance speed control
- New linear DC servomotors now offer axial connectivity
- New sizes for flameproof motor range
- Smart hygienic solutions for the food industry
- The fundamental principles of stepper motors
- ABB launches high power pump motor with advanced rotor design
- ABB introduces new 8 MW high voltage flameproof motor
- Innovative servomotors slash CNC machine building costs
- DC drives from Maxon configured to order
- Energy efficient standard motor range with 40% less losses
- Precision servo positioning for microscope scan stage
- Compact geared motors for precise speed holding
- Simple solution for complex tasks
- High-torque IP65 rated stepper motors
- WEG launches new energy efficient standard motor range at SPS/IPC/Drives 2012
- Ex-stock deliveries for Lafert HPS high efficiency PM motors
- High speed brushless/slotless DC micromotors designed for medical applications
- The hybrid stepper that thinks it's a permanent magnet motor
- Brake motor solution for power failure situations
- Intelligent robots for research and football
- Joining the fight against cancer
- Servo system design
- The quiet revolution
- B&R and Baumüller establish long-term framework supply contract
- Hose-down tolerant smooth bodied stainless steel motors
- Small motor delivers more torque
- Highly flexible servo motor will help machine builders increase productivity and performance
- Leading motors group rebrands in growth drive
- IE4 motor slashes energy consumption by up to 50%
- Detect, secure, and then diffuse
- Integrated servo system is compact
- Saving energy costs with high efficiency motors
- Miniature rotary motor has all the advantages of ceramic motor technology
- Regal makes an entrance to the UK market
- Motors specially developed for lifts and elevators
- WEG launches flameproof motor for hazardous areas
- Linear motors application guide updated
- High efficiency electric motors
- Mars rover finds evidence of water
- Micro annular gear pumps with DC microdrives for precision dosing
- Vac to the future
- NSK adds MECHATROLINK driver unit to Megatorque Motor lineup
- Expanded PM motor range
- Feedback and power in a single cable
- Liquid cooled servo motors deliver double the power
- New protection for Lenze servo drives in extreme conditions
- Coreless motor has best-in-class torque and power performance
- ABB offers full range of IECEx certified IE2 motors
- Linear actuators provide alternative to screw or belt drives
- Small servomotor with big performance
- Understanding linear motor technology
- OEM and Buehler Motor join forces
- A new power storage method uses ABB motor
- Boosting energy efficiency
- Bridging the gap between stepper and servo motors
- Heavy case brushed DC motors from Rotalink
- Smaller frameless torque motors boost reliability
- A step forward in motor function
- Compact servos shorter, lighter and more dynamic
- Robot protects the Amazon Rainforest... with help from Maxon
- Torque motor unmatched for power density
- Aerotech updates linear motors application guide
- Robot protects Amazon Rainforest... with a little help from Maxon
- The inverter motor: compact, energy saving and dynamic
- Further upgrades boost popular motors and planetary gearheads
- Salt no threat to Astrosyn's sealless stepper motors
- Linear motors
- New range of heavy case brushed DC motors from Rotalink
- Maxon unveils newly rebranded EC-4pole brushless motor
- Electric motors
- Motor efficiency upgrades: is it win-win or win-lose
- Motors for medical applications boast an increase in efficiency
- The information you need to cut CO2 emissions
- Injection moulded stepper motors offer higher efficiency in a smaller volume
- A new way to save energy
- ABB first motor maker to receive IECEx conformity mark license
- Integrated steppers are highly compact design
- Mclennan's range grows with Allied Motion lines
- Miniature brushless DC motor range
- Torque motors hold key to reduced energy costs
- Toughened high performance motor range
- Motor sets new benchmark in extreme engineering applications
- Tiny DC servomotor features integrated motion controller
- Brushless motor drives clean up
- Power and control in 3-phases
- Efficient motors
- ATEX motors now available from Huco Dynatork
- Direct drive torque motors are compact
- High efficiency motors for bio-ethanol plant
- Highly efficient stainless steel servo motors
- Nuclear motors
- The most powerful motor on the market
- Tiny motors drive huge water savings
- Diamond Light Source opts for ceramic motors
- Reduced power usage and increased uptime
- Stepper motors position fibre optics in large telescope
- ABB receives IECEx conformity mark licence
- New motor technology nears commercialisation
- Permanent magnet motors come of age
- Staging a revolution
- Versatile DC motors
- Head mounted medical vision system sets new standards
- A revolution in wind power
- Energy efficient servos now in stainless steel
- Energy saving tool for motors
- High efficiency DC motor for demanding hydraulics applications
- Motor boosts efficiency
- Adaptable rear shaft for high torque step motors
- Beat the deadline and start saving now
- Powerful stepper motors
- Flat motor is small but tough
- Motor suits direct drive submarine winch
- Targeting tumours: Maxon drive systems contribute to progress in radiation therapy
- Excitement? It's a racing certainty
- Brushless DC motors integrate speed control electronics
- DC motors
- Fewer parts and reduced maintenance
- In-wheel motors drive the future
- New servo motors top the charts
- Rotor UK boosts its standard motor range
- Compact servo motors bring precise control
- Performance motor brings energy savings
- Space saving option for rotary positioning tasks
- Stainless steel drive products suit outdoor and hygienic tasks
- Electric motors
- Electric motors
- Integrated motor delivers accurate speed control
- Motor design goes modular
- Motors offer precise speed control
- Brushless DC motor range extended
- Modular motors cover all the bases
- Operation is quiet and smooth
- Should you repair or replace that faulty electric motor?
- Stainless motors boost opportunities with new options
- Starter kit simplifies motor evaluation
- Brushless AC servo motors give machine builders options
- Keep it simple without a keeper
- Hybrid stepper motor is flat and small but powerful
- Is copper the answer to the motor efficiency issue?
- Linear motors generate both lift and lateral motion
- Miniature option for linear DC servomotors
- Motor/drive combo ideal for simple tasks