Downtime and costs cut after catastrophic gearbox failure
With O&M costs representing about a quarter of total-life costs for wind power plants, keeping gearboxes functioning properly is crucial to the successful and profitable running of any wind power project. Here, Andrew Baggaley, from Dana SAC UK’s service team, explains how the company cuts downtime and reduces customer costs, through its ability to refurbish and restore.
Dana has recently completed four refurbishment projects of the same gearbox type and same failure mode. These were interesting because the damage was particularly extensive, yet still worth repairing.
This specific design has helical gearing throughout. The case is partly mono block, making both strip down and gear wheel installation challenging. This is due to the risk of cracking the gear case when pressing the wheels off. Dana’s aim is always to investigate the potential for refurbishment, salvaging parts where possible and replacing parts where absolutely necessary.
Andrew Baggaley explains: “Because we were able to inspect four units in the same period, we found them at varying stages of the same failure mode, enabling us to identify the point of initiation. The bearing pairs on the third line were being overloaded. The premature bearing wear had allowed misalignment with the preceding and following lines. Subject to how long the unit was continuing to run, the case bores and – ultimately – the second line wheel and fourth line pinion shaft respectively were also destroyed.”
Thrust overload
On further analysis, the prime contributor to the failure was found to be thrust overload, which could be seen from the asymmetrical bearing inner race wear, (always in the same direction). This had also worn the respective bores.Baggaley explains the assessment: “The gear case was set up and clocked on the horizontal borer. This confirmed that the general accuracy of the gear case was good – parts of both the bore pair were unworn giving us the original centrelines. Accordingly, the line could be re-bored oversize with a counter bore added for a Top Hat flange.
“The low speed shaft interface was also damaged internally where it grips the Input shaft – unusually, the pick-up was caused at original installation when the parts were mated. While many high value components had been essentially written-off, we were keen to find out whether refurbishment was still practically and commercially viable.”
Dana’s servicing team undertook in-depth investigation, resulting in a detailed report, with fully-costed recommendations. Any damage that rendered parts unusable were illustrated and explained; reusable and replacement parts were clearly identified, allowing for accurate rebuild costs to be quoted. Any optional elements and additional recommendations were made clear to the customer.
The build and refurbishment – with new and existing parts – was undertaken by the service team. Bore liners were fitted prior to installing bearings and axial floats set, checked and recorded. As part of the test, paint and dispatch procedure, the internals were reset and gear contacts verified. The unit was spin tested with bearing temperatures monitored to ensure they plateau at an acceptable level. The lube system was also refurbished. These particular units were upgraded. An additional large area high efficiency filter together with a remotely monitored particulate sensor were added. The unit was tested with a throw away filter element, which was then replaced with new on completion ready for despatch.
On completion of the project, Dana were able to return the unit ready to fit, demonstrating that refurbishment can be possible, even for extensive damage, and at less than half the cost of a new unit. With the choice between OEM gear parts or reverse-engineered items, costs to the customer could be further reduced and lead-time cut significantly. All reused parts were subject to NDT (magnetic particle inspection) and new parts and workmanship are covered by a 12-month warranty.
Baggaley comments: “We have seen a number of these types of failure coming through to our servicing team and are confident in our approach which offers significant benefits to the customer. For this project, as with all work undertaken by our servicing team, we focus on minimising disruption and delay in the end use of the unit. Some of the issues uncovered at the investigation stage were potentially very expensive for the customer so our approach, reusing parts where commercially viable and practical, meant that we both kept costs to a minimum as well as avoiding unnecessary delays with the manufacture or delivery lead-time for new parts.
“With more than 30 years combined servicing expertise, our team are experienced with main gearboxes from numerous manufacturers, up to approximately 1MW capacity (V52 size). Having serviced many of this type of gearbox, we’ve added value to some of the most badly damaged units that have been thought unsalvageable.”
Other News from Brevini (UK) Ltd

Latest news about Motors, gears and gearboxes
- Motors for infrared technology systems
- Systems integrator, Quantum Controls, joins Weg distribution network
- Using software and sensors to determine the future of machines
- EMS celebrates official opening of new factory in Dorset
- Weg introduces live remote factory acceptance testing
- Weg publishes guides in four-part series to explain gear technology choices
- Innovative gearboxes for innovative industries
- Construction of Sulzer’s new Birmingham Service Centre on track
- MAXXDRIVE XT gear units provide powerful drive for powerful conveyor belts
- Weg develops anti-viral coating to protect against Covid-19
- Nord drive solutions for the bakery industry
- Challenging offshore repair demands specialist skills
- WEG acquires AI and machine vision start-up
- Nabtesco launches Neco next generation cycloidal gears
- Thomson online selector tool for stepper motor linear actuators simplifies the purchasing experience
- Essentra Components announces high-tech Fluid Absorption Plug
- New service centre for industrial gear units opens in Scotland
- Comau and Tecnomatic join forces
- Maxxdrive industrial gear units: Ideal for heavy-duty applications
- Engineering the future
- Amputee bonds with son thanks to 3D printed bionic hand
- Electric motors address trends in robotics
- Magnomatics shortlisted for Eureka Global Project
- EtherCAT profile for integrated motors
- Gears key to ATM reliability
- Güdel’s new GAdjuster guarantees error free gear mesh adjustment
- Igus extends the functionality of gear configurator for the 3D printing service
- Compact DC motor drives for any application
- Ultra-strong, ultra-light
- SKF helps Houghton International resolve elusive rail motor alternator issue
- Compact and robust geared motors for wiper systems
- Control Techniques introduces standalone remote motor monitor
- Mitsubishi Electric highlights Smart Condition Monitoring at Drives & Controls
- Smart Sensor brings electric motors into the digital age
- Weg introduces Motor Scan monitoring technology
- Maxon chosen for hostile racing cars
- Reliance completes UK Space Agency product development
- Drive component efficiency and their impact on the system
- More power in a compact package
- Compact and modular servo actuator
- Sizing software applies to whole drive train
- RA Rodriguez reports Gear Shop sales up by 81%
- Maxon Motor expands headquarters with new Innovation Centre
- Compact DC motor offers high torque
- Profinet option for brushless motor range
- Sizing software applies to whole drive train
- Linear motors replace pneumatic actuators
- Going with the flow
- Easy Rider
- Motors are just the tip of the iceberg for improving efficiency
- ABB’s new test laboratory helps customers find the ideal motor/drive combination
- Maxon launches record number of new DC motors, gearheads and controllers
- Comparing open and closed loop steppers
- A UK-first in gear manufacturing technology
- Reliance Precision initiates KTP Programme to embed lean culture
- Exico acquired by German motors group, Lammers
- Driving the future of robotics
- High servo power in a compact design
- SEW-Eurodrive launches fully revamped website
- Breaking the buying cycle in power transmission component specification
- Compact underwater DC drives
- When quality and delivery count - motors for every application
- Reliance Precision receives £300k aerospace funding boost
- Air motors stir it up in paint shops
- Motors and drives add to Delta Line’s motion range
- Magnomatics shortlisted for innovation award
- Trommel project benefits from Brevini expertise and support
- The importance of inspecting sutures
- Brevini supplies reliable solutions for ROV handling
- New air sampling pump protects workers' health
- High quality Faulhaber DC Motors now available from RS
- Brevini catalogue for WHL winches
- EMS motors from RS Components
- The tool of choice for compounding pharmacists
- Tattoo machines boost performance with Maxon motors
- Bauer opens flagship production facilities to halve lead time
- Market leaders cooperate to match their drives and motors
- Meeting EN50598 efficiency standard for power drive systems
- New premises enhance service for Lafert UK customers
- Production expansion paves the way for product innovation
- Brevini offers free gearbox training
- Easier motor selection
- New design guide for efficient motors, drives and gears
- Maxon sponsors miniature rescue robot team
- Gear maker targets prestige markets
- Magnomatics announces The Proving Factory as production partner
- Magnomatics joins consortium developing aerospace actuators
- The next best thing to reinventing the wheel
- Holroyd secures £2.75 million order from leading Chinese ice systems specialist
- Maintain accuracy with anti-backlash gears
- Selecting servo geared motors
- Siemens invests a further £1 million in UK mechanical drives
- Electronic motor starter ensures simpler, faster, error-free installation
- Showcasing innovative Yorkshire businesses for The Grand Départ
- Brevini invests in aftermarket services to help users minimise downtime
- The next generation of hybrid engines
- Customised gear technology
- RA Rodriguez at Drives and Controls 2014
- The big space spring clean
- Compact motors, thousands of options
- RA Rodriguez extends European Network
- High performance in smaller sizes
- High torque in a tiny package
- SEW Eurodrive moves to new purpose built plant
- Magnetic gear at the heart of innovative CVT design
- Innovation for robotic drilling - passive input gearbox
- Pioneering device could give transplants a boost
- Keyless versus keyed connections between motors and gearboxes
- Electric motors take to the skies with the Dreamliner
- Power in miniature
- Sustainable motion solutions
- Vacuum rated gears help test ion thrust propulsion system
- Gearheads offer more mounting options
- Antivibration mounts for motors
- Maximum precision, dynamics, durability and efficiency
- The cost of downtime is a simple equation
- Delta Line appointed distributor for Zeitlauf in the UK
- Backlash versus lost motion
- Brevini opens new winch stock and service centre
- A new dimension in perfection
- XXL - High performance bevel gearheads
- Bevel gears from Ondrives
- Cast iron wheels from Ondrives
- Commercial parallel helical gears from Ondrives
- Delrin and Peek precision gears from Ondrives
- Delrin and Peek worms and wheels from Ondrives
- Internal and double spur gears from Ondrives
- Ondrives introduces crossed axis helical gears
- Ondrives introduces spur gear racks range
- Ondrives launches precision worms and wheels
- Ondrives launches skive hobbed gears
- Ondrives launches titanium precision gear range
- Precision gear racks from Ondrives
- Same day, build to order gearbox service
- Hidden technology transforms poker millionaire's penthouse table for play
- Siemens Gears Up With £1.2M Leeds Plant
- Reduced energy consumption on bottling line
- A story of fast turnaround gear cutting success
- Linear chain and geared motors meet the needs of stage and theatre applications
- Marine order
- Power transmission
- Power transmission
- Tiny drive shows a lot of bottle
- Wind turbine gearbox dryer protects lubrication oil
- Air motors
- EMS expands its UK manufacturing facility to support growth
- Motors matched with gears, brakes, controllers and drives
- Low cost gearmotors for miniature power transmission
- Miniature motors, gears and actuators
- The energy saving benefits of the latest air motor products
- Upgrade features Flender gear units
- Motors and gears
- Parvalux transfers EMD operations to Bournemouth
- Medical automation technologies
- Miniature motors for medical applications
- More powerful and smoother than ever
- Precision positioning capability sets these air motors apart
- DC motors
- Motors and drives
- Brushless DC motors
- Italian gears added to growing power transmission range
- Micro motors range extended
- Offset spur reduction gearboxes
- Planetary gearhead at the heart of highly compact new rotary actuator
- Preventing Electric Motor failure
- Replacement drive system keeps Severn Trent on track
- Gearboxes extend range for spindle drives
- Compact linear motors get direct to the point
- Disc armature motors outperform conventional iron cored designs
- Exactly what defines a high efficiency motor?
- Gearmotors are compact and powerful
- Motors suit applications where durability is key
- Right handed gearhead is a rugged all-rounder
- Steppers provide more consistent torque output
- Air motors - the complete works
- Direct drive servos are energy efficient
- Hard anodised rack and pinion actuator boxes
- Motors and positioning systems catalogue
- Starship drives fan power expansion
- The worm has turned
- When the going gets tough, go for vacuum
- Steel magnolia
- Beating space constraints with planetary drives
- Electric motors
- Incorrectly sized servos could cost industry dear
- Making the case for solid state contactors
- Motors suit tight spots in demanding environments
- Noise tests reveal quietest air motor
- Save energy without replacing your existing motors
- New stock gear catalogue
- Power transmission product catalogue
- Dual forcer linear motor can double your productivity
- Precision rotary actuators
- Quality gears range includes plastic versions
- Gears hollow out a niche for motion control tasks
- German machine tool builder turns tables using wormgears
- Performance gears on short delivery
- Air motor is fully submersible
- Direct drive rotary stages
- Do you want even more power?
- How do you choose the right motor starter?
- Meeting the needs of demanding environments
- Pharmaceutical finish for stainless steel motors
- Small servo motor for tough tasks
- A fresh breeze for gears
- Combining motors and drives
- Beating motor failure
- Expanded range of servo geared motors
- Explosion-proof geared motors
- No more gearbox problems
- Planetary gearboxes from stock
- Quiet and efficient geared motors
- Speedy standard geared motors
- Gearbox meets conveyor drive requirements
- Fast pay back on stainless motor
- Motors meet defence industry needs
- Servo motors boost torque
- Steppers boost low speed torque
- At the forefront of advances in fuel cell technology
- Baldor signs Routeco as motor distributor
- Brammer opens Newport centre
- David Brown Engineering assists in steel mill upgrade
- Free gears catalogue
- Getting a new lease of life
- Repair or replace service for Royal Navy frigates
- Banishing the jitters
- Compact DC servo motors
- Going into Hiperdrive
- Servo technology from EMS
- Unique motor system solutions
- Flender FZG gear units available from Bradford
- Improved reliability and precision at Winbro
- Slimline gearbox drives elevator innovation
- Stainless steel motors improve cheese production
- ZF gearbox keeps flight simulation on schedule
- High performance linear motors
- More options for brushless servos
- New brand for AC motors
- Power boosted, quality maintained
- Right angle servo gearheads
- A wider range of gearboxes
- High efficiency DC motor for operation in harsh conditions
- Improved protection for heat exchanger motors
- Motor and gearbox package is totally stainless
- Neeter Drive launches P54 and X54 bevel gearboxes
- New motors from Ondrives
- Shaft mounted speed reducers are maintenance free
- High efficiency brake motors
- Linear motor first to get UL approval
- Micromotors are small and short
- More than just simple feedback
- Plug and play motor gear unit
- Polished performance from servo motors
- Small motors are big news
- All-metric, three-phase stainless steel motors
- Brake motors meet safety standards
- Custom motors are at home at sea
- Drive element makes more of wind energy
- Hollow shaft option for gears
- Marines to get lighter guns
- Meeting demands for zero engineering cost
- More force from a linear motor
- Three phases are better than two
- Upgrade for flameproof motor range
- Wyko saves Thames Water both time and money