Money saving fallacy of hose re-ending
Quality is probably one of the most important metrics in the industrial world. When people pay for a product or service, they expect to get the best possible solution to their needs – not just in terms of cost, but also fitness for purpose, capabilities and, of course, safety.
Like so many things in life however, the expression “you only get what you pay for” rings true; with lower costs often equating to less exacting workmanship, increased wear, reduced operational life, or, indeed, all three. If you have money to burn, this is your choice, but when safety is a major part of the equation, you must consider if your short-term cost savings are really the most prudent – and ethical or even legal – course of action.
It is for this very reason – to help people make these sorts of decisions and to promote best practice – that standards exist to cover almost all facets of the industrial universe. The problem is, if these standards are not enforceable under law, you must rely on people applying them from a best-practice standpoint.
It is in these situations that trade bodies play a vital role, ensuring and supporting their members to adhere to good engineering practice – not only to bolster quality and the reputation of the industry, but also to ensure that any safety concerns are readily explained, understood and adhered to. A case in point would be the British Fluid Power Distributor’s Association’s (BFPDA) Approved Hose Assemblies Scheme. Since its introduction in 1995, the scheme’s ‘Q-Approved’ logo has become a recognised symbol of quality, integrity and safety in the fluid power industry.
Comprising an accreditation process and resulting customer assurances, the scheme – developed by a panel of industry experts, including members of the BFPDA and BFPA – sets an industry-wide standard for the assembly, storage and supply of hydraulic hoses. As well as delivering best-practice guidelines, it also counters and addresses the health and safety issues associated with the risky practice of re-ending hoses. The core message behind these guidelines is that best practice recommends, very plainly, that you don’t re-end hoses.
At the core of the scheme are the guidelines laid down by international standards. They state that all hose assembly practices must conform to the international recommendations within BS EN ISO 4413 and BS EN ISO 4414, and meet the guidelines. Both are Harmonised Standards of the Machinery Directive, which is written into legislation.
Clause 5.4.6.5.1 a) – within ‘BS EN ISO 4413 Hydraulic Fluid Power – General rules and safety requirements for systems and their components’ states: “Hose assemblies shall be constructed from hoses that have not been previously used in operation as part of another hose assembly and that fulfil all performance and marking requirements given in appropriate standards.” It is worth noting at this stage that in CEN and ISO parlance, the word ‘shall’ is taken as ‘must comply’ – it is non-negotiable. It is therefore quite clear that the international standard is intent to outlaw the re-ending of flexible hydraulic hoses. The scheme also adheres to BS EN ISO 4414, which mirrors this advice for pneumatic hoses.
Trade associations, industry experts and health and safety bodies all agree that you simply don’t re-end hoses, the risks are too great; but the problem is that hose re-ending is still prevalent across much of the industry, with most people citing cost as the primary rationale.
“It is hard to convince people to hand over £200 for a new hose assembly, when they can get it re-ended for £50,” explains Pirtek’s Martyn Smart. “With cost being such a defining factor, it’s a real battle to convince them otherwise. I have seen 2,000 psi water jet hoses repaired with tape and a jubilee clip. Counter this with the fact that we have purchased and delivered over 4,000 BFPA books detailing the impact of fluid injection injuries and you can see that the message just isn’t getting through – especially when bottom lines are a defining factor in the decision.”
Andy Dickens, operations manager at Interpump Hydraulics (UK), adds: “Companies are put under huge commercial pressures, so much so that re-ending is seen as the commercially attractive alternative.” Backing up Martyn Smart, he adds: “We have seen hoses repaired with a bundle of gaffer tape. People don’t seem to appreciate just how much pressure these systems are under. There is a massive amount of naivety, with people being blissfully unaware of the dangers of high-pressure fluid systems.”
Smart comments: “A hose made from a ‘pick-and-mix’ of third-party components simply cannot guarantee the tolerances necessary to ensure a quality hose assembly. Add to this the fact that you didn’t know the operational history of the hose being re-ended and you have a potential recipe for disaster. No one will offer a guarantee or warranty on a re-end.
“We use matched components, all of which are tested by their manufacturers to meet tolerances, which for a swaged ferrule are +0mm/–0.2 mm.”
Dickens adds to this: “When you’re re-ending, you’re mixing and matching components. The products may appear to be the same, but there are differences. Our ferrules fit our hoses. If you use a third-party ferrule that’s at the upper end of the tolerance band, it may not fit properly. I’m not saying that ours are better – they just match our hoses. Anyone who’s done a re-end has lost those tolerances. Where are they getting measurement information from? Whose data are they using?”
And Smart explains: “There is an extreme amount of force trying to push these components apart. In its own right it is hard to put into words, but we have showcased it by setting up an assembly with a mis-manufactured hose, which is then put under 350 Bar of pressure. In this instance, it blew within 15 seconds and decimated a 3kg melon we had put next to it. We had to use a 2,000 frames per second camera to catch the failure and resulting impact. The hose end was measured at 600 feet per second – similar to the muzzle velocity of a rifle.”
The consensus from Smart, Dickens and the BFPA is that hydraulic hoses need to be addressed with the same level of importance and attention to detail that you would give to any precision engineered component. In addition to the simple cost of replacement, users must consider the cost of failure, from both a financial and a cost perspective.
Only by using hoses from suppliers accredited by the BFPDA’s Approved Hose Assemblies Scheme, can users have the confidence that they have purchased an assembly that has undergone rigorous measurement and testing; assemblies that use matched components that are within defined tolerances and are backed by industry wide guidelines.
“The more we educate people, the better and safer the industry will become,” Smart concludes. “Hoses will get damaged in their everyday use. We need users to consider how and where they are used and then develop a proactive inspection and maintenance plan. This way, early failures can be more easily predicted and even have their causes designed out. Some protective systems are highly effective and are more palatable in cost terms versus replacement.”
Dickens adds: “None of us seem to know who is doing this re-ending. But it is still going on. We will replace entire assemblies that have failed testing rather than elements of it, even though it costs us more. This is how committed we are to the safety of users, as should all of industry. We are then confident to offer warranties; which leads me onto an interesting final thought: re-ends do not come with any form of warranty or guarantee. Would you be prepared to purchase any other product without these in place?”

British Fluid Power Association
Other News from British Fluid Power Association

Latest news about Hydraulic components
- Eaton launches cost-competitive Winner PTFE hoses for demanding applications
- Flexicon extends its liquid-tight conduit system range with UL and CSA certification
- Helping OEMs bring new machine features to market
- Eaton launches a new Multiplate system enabling faster and simpler connectivity for Flat Face Series Quick Disconnect Couplings
- Moog Modular Electrohydrostatic Actuation System (EAS) combines the best of two worlds
- Particle contamination monitor performs test procedure in under 90 seconds
- Bonomi UK launches new website and digital catalogue
- Eaton’s new CMT mobile valve section increases design flexibility
- Very high speed solenoid valves increase semiconductor production output
- Engineering Expertise from Eaton Hydraulics UK keeps the blades turning
- Dispense pumps meet the growing fluidic challenges of evolving medical-IVD instruments
- Elesa launches new FH modular coolant hose system
- Air bleed orifice improves efficiencies in hydraulic systems
- Essentra Components produces free guide to hydraulic hose protection
- Hycrocam hydraulic bolt tensioners remove uncertainty from couplings
- Bürkert solenoid valve tackles dezincification and water hammer
- Thermoplastic hydraulic hoses and fittings designed to work together, enabling safe and effective fluid conveyance
- 5 facts about hydraulics that may surprise you
- Miniature solenoid valve offers high flow and low leakage
- Moog and Voith to form strategic partnership
- Charting the right course to efficiency in the marine industry
- Greater flexibility for high pressure applications
- Hydraulic handbook is packed with useful data
- Filtermist to demonstrate how it helps workers ‘Go Home Healthy’
- Elesa level monitoring accessories and labelling provision simplify hydraulic systems
- VHS appointed Bosch Rexroth integrator
- Absorbing water from hydroscopic oils
- Eaton Hydraulics invests in state-of-the-art training facility
- Solenoid valve key to brake innovation
- Stauff demonstrates innovations in hydraulic components and accessories at Fluid Power & Systems 2018
- Hose selection is critical to minimising fire risk
- Latching solenoid valve saves energy
- VHS Hydraulic Components acquires Nielson Hydraulics
- Hose combines high pressure with long cycle life
- Hydraulics will run and run with proper servicing
- Plugs are designed to seal cross port passageways
- Lee Products publishes 9th edition of EFS handbook
- A match made in heaven
- Bosch Rexroth Hydraulics Roadshow is hailed a huge success
- New ATEX hydraulic accessories from Elesa
- Elesa breather caps and level indicators hit the mark for Sarum Hydraulics
- Best practice is vital in hydraulic fluid selection
- In-line wash flow safety screens take filtration to a higher level
- How to control hydraulic flow rates more efficiently
- Staying safe with hydraulic hoses
- Bespoke test rig installation completed
- Lee restrictors keep the electricity on
- Miniature inert solenoid pumps offer flexibility
- Gas charging test kit product range
- The risks of outdated separators
- Controllers for precision hydraulic motion
- The importance of security in today’s connected world
- Manufacturer keeps UK hydraulics industry alive in Singapore
- Tom Parker introduces the FasTest range
- Pressure Hydraulics Cork recognised as Ireland’s first Bosch Rexroth Authorised Training Centre
- Liquid cooling for enclosures
- Slots versus holes improve flow through safety screens
- Ultra-compact, energy-efficient solenoid valves save space and reduce weight
- Brammer announces new partnership
- Hydraulic Components catalogue
- Hydraulic hose assembly
- Reliable tube connection system for extreme conditions
- The show goes on for RSC thanks to hydraulic cylinders
- Trio of success caps off growth year for hydraulics specialist
- Top ten tips – oil analysis
- Vestas choose Bosch Rexroth for hydraulic power unit
- Connectors: clean break, flat face or double shut off?
- Report highlights maintenance failings in UK manufacturing
- The hydraulic fluid 'laboratory in a suitcase'
- Ultra-miniature solenoid valves save space and use less energy
- Robust, lightweight PEEK safety screens
- Strainers provide coarse level filtration without pressure drop
- Big savings in oil filtration for aerospace
- Investment to meet growing demand
- Failure to conduct oil checks a "major cause" of hydraulic failure
- New connector for sterile processes
- Miniature inert solenoid valve protects sensitive fluids
- Miniature, chemically inert stepper dispense pump
- Strainers provide coarse level filtration without pressure drop
- Liquid cooling for enclosures
- Solenoid valves - there's one for every occasion
- Industry 4.0 - concepts and practical solutions
- Miniature medical grade check valve ideal for plastic manifolds
- BFPA and BCAS form UK Motion Control Alliance
- A 'hands-on' opportunity in Telford
- Miniature servo actuators bring high power density to Formula 1
- Stauff UK and GR Motosport unveil Connect Academy
- High pressure flow restrictors for critical applications
- Moog delivers tyre coupled simulation system to Mazda
- Neilson Hydraulics goes back to new with Bosch Rexroth
- Piedrafita selects Moog for fatigue test system
- Bosch Rexroth launches oil analysis service to reduce machine downtime
- Oil contamination identified as a major cause of machinery failure
- Miniature burst plugs provide over-pressure protection
- New gear pump design offers near silent forklift operation
- Eaton's low-temperature hydraulic hose serves mining and construction
- Hydraulics
- Bosch Rexroth opens new service and training centre in Wakefield
- Accurate positioning and adjustment of equipment
- Tom Parker brings new range to the UK market
- Precision microhydraulic components solve critical problems of size and weight
- Miniature electro-fluidic systems from Lee Products
- Bosch Rexroth gives legs to walking robot
- A short guide to selecting quick release fluid connectors
- Bosch Rexroth expands into filtration market
- Electro fluid systems guide
- New EFS handbook published by Lee Products
- UK sales and service partner for Sauer Danfoss
- NACE compliant safety screens for extreme applications
- Ultra-fine safety screens are robust
- Fluid Control
- Safe fluid power
- Bright future ahead as Bosch Rexroth breaks ground in Wakefield
- Configure hydraulic solutions
- Inert solenoid pump sets new standards of design flexibility
- Gas springs operate in conjunction with electro-hydraulic lifting system
- The business benefits of upgrading hydraulic systems
- Equipment for use in hazardous areas
- The essential companion throughout hydraulics and pneumatics industries
- Hydraulics for subsea operations
- Bosch Rexroth completes Hägglunds Acquisition
- Safety holds the key to improved business performance
- Compact piston type open circuit pumps
- Hydraulics distribution
- Independent, highly dynamic linear axis
- Multiple pumps with reduced overall length
- Eaton's hydraulics help free the Chilean miners
- Dampers key in support vessel safety system
- Fluid connectors
- Keeping your fluids clean
- Atomising nozzles deliver precise spray pattern
- Parker plays crucial role in military projects
- Hydroscopic breathers boost performance
- New hydraulic power packs
- Going with the flow on green energy
- Oil level indicators in brass and stainless steel
- Replacement filters enhance profitability
- Edbro success in tilt test trials
- Parker distributor BSP Hydraulics expands into marine sector
- Fluid control catalogue highlights Burkert's wide range
- Micro nozzles for delicate washdown applications
- Compact, light valve for high pressure charging
- Hydraulics and electronics combine in stored energy management system
- New handbook for hydraulic and pneumatic components
- An engineering guide to miniature fluid control components
- Connector approved to key hydraulic standard
- Couplings for medical applications
- BFPA hosts major standards meeting
- Microfluidics
- Miniature orifice saves weight and space
- Hydraulic Fluids
- High speed solenoid valves for micro dispensing
- Highly accurate screened orifice for medical applications
- Leak-free plugs handle high pressures
- Lightweight valves ideal for OEM flow switching
- Miniature solenoid valve sets new standards
- High pressure cartridge screens block rogue contaminants
- Micro inert valve needs less space and uses less power
- Micro-dispense nozzles for optimum system flexibility
- Miniature check valve for harsh duty applications
- Miniature insert orifice saves weight and space
- Miniature pumps help make a smaller machine, better
- Miniature relief valve ensures zero leakage
- Miniature shuttle valve ideal for hydraulic isolation
- Power generation Chek valves are field serviceable
- VHS solenoid valve manifold ideal for flow injection tasks
- Zero leak check valves suit critical flow control systems
- Control two circuits from just one hydraulic source
- End caps protect and isolate
- Rugged safety screens handle twice the pressure
- Cleaner, faster, smarter, safer drum connections
- Innovative connectors simplify seal test line construction
- Steel cam couplings offer quick release
- Cylinders designed to boost productivity
- New 90 litre bi-directional poppet valves
- Logic element combines flexibility with performance
- New premises for Hydrastore marks expansion
- When is a repair not a real repair
- Reducing the hazards of analysis
- Hydraulic power for innovative milking systems
- Parker brings particle analysis out of the lab
- Pump design offers big benefits in stationary hydraulic applications
- Helping to minimise environmental damage
- Hydraulics performs in the leisure industry
- That sinking feeling - with complete digital accuracy
- Two-stage breather cap
- High performance filters
- How to capitalise from your component breakdowns
- Bosch Rexroth lands its biggest ever order
- Parker Hannifin launches its cylinder repair service
- Taking sides on suction and return filtration
- Hydraulic rams and block cylinders
- Needle type flow control valves
- Absolutely leak-free larger couplings
- High pressure plug for venting applications
- Compact valve protects in the event of sudden failure
- Leak-free connections speed endoscope reprocessing
- Bosch Rexroth takes electrohydraulics to the next level
- Valves meet needs for higher flow rates
- The smallest solenoid valve in the world
- Couplings make fluid transfer simple and safe
- Proportional flow control valve
- Hydraulics power two Iraqi bascule bridges
- Multi-function screw-in valve